The 30-year-old Klaas H. from Friesland, gets three months in prison in Myanmar for sacrilege. He has also been fined $105, which has already been paid. This prevents forced labor from being performed. 

It is still unclear whether he will appeal against his hefty prison sentence. His pre-trial detention will be deducted from the three months.

Some time ago, the 30-year-old man unplugged an amplifier that was used in a Buddhist ritual. He said he did because the noise prevented him from sleeping. His Hotel was near the temple. He walked into the building where the noise was coming from in his shoes and asked if it could be turned down a bit. When there was no response, he pulled the plug from the sound system.

He stated at an earlier hearing that he was very sorry and that he did not know that he had entered a temple.

What do the readers of Thailandblog think of this punishment? Too heavy or just right? Let us know and also why.

44 responses to “Dutch tourist gets three months in prison for sacrilege in Myanmar”

  1. Daniel M. says up

    I don't know what to think about this.

    It is easy to say in hindsight “he should have done”…

    We also don't know to what extent he was aware of the culture and the 'do's ant don'ts'.

    As a normal tourist, I would rather opt for a heavier fine instead of a penalty, because that penalty may force him to rebook his return flight (and pay the 'full pot') and his visa will also expire. He must therefore immediately book overnight stays again in anticipation of his return journey. In other words, it requires a very organizational approach. Then I have not yet talked about the arrangements with his employer in the Netherlands and the possible consequences…

    I also believe that imprisonment will also have lasting psychological consequences for this young man. I've heard stories about Thai prisons…

    Hopefully he will get a reduced sentence and he can go home soon.

    Good luck!

  2. Chris from the village says up

    On the one hand , I can understand him well ,
    because I live near a temple.
    I too was already dreaming about unplugging
    to draw , but I'm not stupid enough to do this
    really do.
    On the other hand, he now has 3 months
    to think about his stupid reaction .
    It could also have ended worse for him.

  3. erik says up

    Your message is different from the one in The Nation; they are talking about three months in prison + hard labor and $ 80 to avoid another three months in prison for violating the visa rules. Now I don't mind the $80 or $105, but forced labor is an additional factor. This is the link to The Nation:
    http://www.nationmultimedia.com/breakingnews/Myanmar-jails-Dutch-tourist-for-pulling-plug-on-Bu-30297055.html

    As far as the punishment is concerned, you are in a different world than the Netherlands where disrupting a sermon is viewed differently. And maybe there are countries where you would be stoned to death for such an evil prank. He should have known better and can now sit on the blisters; luckily for him, winter sets in there too.

  4. Jasper says up

    To be honest, what bothers me most is that he "had to cry" when he heard the verdict. 3 months is a very light sentence for sacrilege. A New Zealander was previously sentenced to 2 1/2 years in Myanmar for showing an image of Buddha with earphones on his business's Facebook page.
    He might have known, if he hadn't been so arrogant.

    I also once woke up in a cheap hotel in Istanbul, it turned out that we were -unbelievably- 10 meters away from a minaret where prayer was proclaimed at 4 o'clock in the morning. Country wise, country honour.
    Then turned me back.
    Otherwise better not travel abroad.

  5. Do says up

    Let's hope it also has a preventive effect. People sometimes do very stupid things in other countries. And then think that just saying 'sorry' can really be more than enough.

  6. Henk says up

    I really can't understand how someone can act so stupid, you don't do this in the Netherlands.
    And do you really think he didn't know it was a temple, you can tell by the music,
    or was it too soft.
    A piece of advice: behave yourself here in the Netherlands, but certainly in other countries, you won't get into any problems.

  7. John Hoekstra says up

    Monks are forgiving, I think 3 months is a bit exaggerated for this cultural barbarian. That, of course, was not in his Lonely Planet, "Thou shalt not disturb the sermon of monks by unplugging plugs."

  8. Nik says up

    When you visit a country, you should inform yourself about the cultural customs. I think it's extremely rude what he did. Pack your things and find another guesthouse that is not near a temple. Earplugs in. It's all so obvious.
    But no, the people of Myanmar have to adapt to the Westerner who needs his nap…
    Don't have a good word for this. Join Chris: 3 months to think about it. Linea recta back to Fryslan and never leave again..

    • if says up

      must stay at home from now on if he wants to arrange things abroad as well. he is a guest in Myanmar, so behave accordingly, just as a foreigner should adapt here.

  9. leon1 says up

    Prepare yourself when you go to another country and respect the other culture, if you can't muster that, you should stay away.
    To be honest, he could have easily spent a year in prison for me, then he would have been cured of his arrogance for good.

    • D. Brewer says up

      Everything within limits.
      They are not that good there, witness the crimes against the Rohingya.
      A monetary penalty would have been more than enough.

  10. patrick says up

    his story is worth big money for the tabloids. if he does it right and takes care of an agent who specializes in this, he will certainly not be poorer.
    by the way, not only the tabloids, also think of national geographic with its series “banged up abroad”.
    he can also publish a book, or give lectures to tell his story.
    maybe a movie.
    every challenge creates new opportunities.
    3 months in a prison in Myanmar, it seems like a unique story.

  11. Sheng says up

    It may sound annoying … but 100% right. How do you get it into your head to get other people's stuff. Stupid stupid stupid… Always shouting that people have to adapt to our rules (rightly so) but then I read such an action again….Pff you are making a tour of a year…and then you start to get annoyed about something like that. How privileged I am to be able to have such a great experience of a year….and then over something so small such a response…. http://www.volkskrant.nl/buitenland/nederlander-krijgt-drie-maanden-cel-voor-heiligschennis-myanmar~a4390383/

  12. Angele Gyselaers says up

    Traveling is learning; also respect for the traditions of the country and this man should have known that shoes should be taken off if one belongs to a house, here a temple! Sawadee.

  13. Paul says up

    I think the entire action shows contempt for the morals, customs and religion of the people. I encounter it so often here in Thailand. Sometimes I ask what people come here to do if you don't like all this and everything is so much better in your own country. I am seen as Thai by both foreigners and Thais because of my appearance. Because of this, many foreigners treat me like a stupid Thai (in their own words). The surprise is that this stupid Thai suddenly turns out to speak 8 languages, understands them and responds in their own language. Personally, I think he should get off with a very lenient sentence. As far as I'm concerned, let this be a lesson for the future.

  14. Bert Boersma says up

    Own fault. He is an experienced traveler and knows how things work in those countries.
    It is the arrogance of the Westerner.
    I know it's very irritating that noise coming from such a temple, but you don't have to interfere.
    I have been coming to these countries for 25 years and I know the consequences of such an intervention.
    He still comes off graciously. I had thought at least 1 to 2 years.

  15. Renee Martin says up

    He should have informed himself more about things when you visit a country, but if you read in the media how aggressive people became after his act, pull the plug because of the noise, then you may wonder what the core of their 'faith' is. I myself think that there is little compassion for this boy and I hope for his sake that he can leave the prison sooner.

  16. Victor Kwakman says up

    Fine punishment. It should be over with people who think they can do everything with impunity without knowledge and/or respect. The Asian world differs greatly from the Western world, everyone who travels to Asia should know that.

  17. anna says up

    all nice and nice but maybe people should learn to respect other cultures.
    And I can assume that if you travel the world and visit certain countries that you read up.
    I'm fine with him getting 3 months and he'll probably get out sooner.
    People should learn that not everything is possible just because you happen to be a tourist

  18. Martin says up

    He will go to jail in Myanmar, not Thailand. I don't know if that's an advantage, I don't think it gets much worse.

    “I didn't know it was a temple” sorry, but I don't believe any of that, and at 22.00:XNUMX PM “can't sleep…” also sounds very believable.

    Whether he regrets his action, I rather think he regrets the consequences. He seems to me to have little respect for his host country.

    That he has to organize a lot, yes, a pity, think before you start, if you commit offenses in another country, you have to take into account local penalties, that they are different or annoying, yes………

    Hope he has learned something from it, I have little pity for someone who, as a guest, unplugs the sound system somewhere, that a monk is praying does not seem to me to be something you "overlook".

  19. T says up

    Well I don't mind it, I think this person knew very well what he was doing and he thought he could get away with it as a Westerner. Do you know what I found ridiculous that man who had to sit in jail in Thailand for more than 6 months without any prospect of help from the Dutch state. work without the proper permit. And who had to be helped by a TV program. But I don't mind this so much he was cool when he made his action and now has to sit on the blisters and can just go after 3 months and a fine of less than 100 euros what are we talking about.

  20. Fransamsterdam says up

    Actually, it's not up to us to judge that, but go ahead.
    I find three months for sacrilege very acceptable if you compare it to the Netherlands where you are soon sentenced to five months for insulting people of flesh and blood (the tea light holder thrower).
    The speed with which the justice system in Myanmar functions also deserves a compliment, when we see that the tea light holder ultimately spent two years in prison (of which 19 months were unjustified).

  21. Hank Hauer says up

    I think he's a stupid figure. He has himself to blame. He was also lucky, the maximum sentence is 2 years.
    Due to mass tourism, this kind of thing will occur even more, because now everyone can travel and many think that one can behave as in the home country. Where misbehavior is usually covered with the cloak of love

  22. KLAUS HARDER says up

    I don't want to repeat myself, I've said it enough times now, that was the height of stupid arrogance (Yes, there is such a thing as intelligent arrogance) ..... and you can count the consequences by 'one' finger. If our Christian God has any mercy on him, maybe, just maybe, his lawyer can buy it off. (But that will cost a small fortune) ;O)

  23. Edward says up

    Sorry but I think it is a justified punishment, if you are in another country then you have to comply with the rules there, in principle 3 months for such an offense in a Buddhist country are not that long, but 3 months between strictly religious criminals is or damn long, you can count on his future buddies knowing what he's in for, I wish him all the best and a healthy return to the Netherlands.

  24. Tino Kuis says up

    Jesus, what bloodthirsty reactions all. Lock him up for a year.

    'We must respect all cultures' everyone shouts. Oh yeah? Who respects the culture of Saudi Arabia? Not me. And as for the Buddhist culture in Burma this one:

    'In 2013, 20 Muslim schoolchildren were among 40 people massacred by a Buddhist mob in Meiktila, south of Mandalay, after an argument broke out in a Muslim-owned gold shop' The Australian, 5 December 2015.

    In the case of a 'crime', the intention also plays a role. He had no intention of committing sacrilege. This man was mentally disturbed and did something stupid, period. No one was harmed. Hurt feelings? Some Muslims and Christians react so strongly to that. Right in your opinion? A cartoon about Mohammed and a year in prison? That's what you say.

    Fine, apology and out of the country.

    • Khan Peter says up

      I had also said in a first primary reaction that three months was an appropriate punishment. That, in retrospect, is nonsense. A few nights in jail, a fine and expulsion from the country would have been enough.
      Incidentally, this is again proof that no belief or belief brings anything good. Even peaceful Buddhism is abused by followers. The monks and the Burmese therefore do not understand at all what the Buddha was trying to convey.

  25. D. Brewer says up

    3 Months in jail , …… Insanity.
    A fine was more than enough.
    A well-known communist from the past said:

    Faith is….. For the people.

    • Jer says up

      There is also such a thing as decency and social skills. He didn't have either at the time.

      I thought it was an appropriate punishment: 3 months of sweeping the temple grounds, helping to clean the kitchen and toilets in a temple and 3 months of getting up at 04.00 a.m. in the morning.

  26. Ruud NK says up

    A very stupid area. But 3 months in jail will break him up. I hope he survived among the Buddhist inmates. If I had the choice, I would rather be stuck in the Netherlands for 3 years than 3 months there. His family is also punished, because without someone outside the prison who can provide him with anything and everything, he will not make it. He will not lose this experience for the rest of his life. Stupid and my own fault yes, but I feel sorry for him.

  27. bona says up

    Those who cannot behave according to the norms and laws of the country where they are staying must also accept the sanctions! I do not see how any person would ignore the culture of Saudi Arabia, for example, and consume pork and alcohol, among other things, and consider the consequences exaggerated. Respect and respect for the current rules and customs of a country are paramount!
    Of course there will always be individuals who feel elevated above that.

    • Tino Kuis says up

      So bona, you don't think it's an exaggeration at all that you are beheaded in Saudi Arabia for 1 atheism 2 leaving Islam 3 sodomy and lesbian acts 4 blasphemy 5 treason 6 witchcraft 7 smuggling alcohol and a number of other very serious crimes? Confessions through torture are commonplace in that country.

      And you have respect and reverence for that? Well not me. I feel far above that.

      Of course you have to adhere to the usual rules and customs in a country, if only to avoid ending up in jail. But always respect and reverence? Didn't see me.

      • Chris says up

        Always respect, agreeing is something else. No respect for things that go against fundamental human rights, but which ones are also different per country. We in the Netherlands also have things that people in many other countries take note of with surprise and sometimes with horror. Take, for example, the regulated sale of drugs.

      • bona says up

        To clear up a misunderstanding: I find the sanctions in Saudi Arabia absolutely inhumane! Therefore, I will never visit a country with such laws!
        When one decides to visit a country, one must adhere to the laws and customs of the country. If you are bothered by too much noise, just change hotels or the like, but don't take the law into your own hands!

  28. Frank says up

    Well, contempt is still punished in these countries. Could we learn something from it. Respect is hard to find in the Netherlands, let alone being punished. Before you go on holiday, you should still use it and know the do's and don'ts of the holiday destination, I think. It is of course a pity for him, but hey who bounces the ball….

  29. Henk says up

    So, given the reactions of all writers, there is never anyone who is annoyed by the very loud music?
    No one who behaves differently in a country where other norms and values ​​apply.
    I am now 15 meters away with noise of 85 db.
    This starts at 7am and ends around midnight.
    That for 10 days.
    There is no one who finds it annoying to sit in all the noise in, for example, the tesco lotus?
    You can't have a decent conversation. But yes, you can't do that with a Thai, it will be a reaction.
    Perhaps the Guesthouse should also have told guests that there are monks within earshot with noisy worship.
    Of course he should have found another solution.
    Perhaps his girlfriend should have intervened.
    However, we don't know the situation because no one has been there.
    We all condemn him.
    But when the death penalty is carried out in a number of countries, we scream bloody murder. Even if it concerns drug-related activities.
    There are even writers here who think 3 months is too short.
    A fine was in order. Prison sentence? No, that's disproportionate.
    Country wise country honour.
    Yes, only within reasonable limits.
    We are guests in a country with different laws and regulations.
    But if something happens to yourself such as a traffic violation where you are blamed because you are a foreigner, we scream bloody murder.
    About the differences in price between Thai and farang?
    We complain if we think it's unfair. Read Thailand blog.
    This is also a rule that applies in Thailand, among others.
    Oh well, that's different cases and then suddenly we want the rules to be adjusted.
    With and with 2 sizes.
    People go first see what the situation is and then judge.
    I also unplugged them from the neighbor across the street in the past.
    After a few weeks this started to get very annoying. She was 84 years old. Nitrogen. Radio outside at full blast. Tried to negotiate several times.
    Even offered to buy headphones.
    Nothing helped. Still, the police were called in. Sitting outside was impossible.
    The police have tried several times to solve it. Radio confiscated. However son just bought a new one.
    Finally just pulled the plug. Well it didn't get through.
    So I understand his action. And yes, you reflect on the comments.
    I wish strength to everyone who lives next to a temple.
    And also those who have neighbors who also have the volume knob on 1 position.
    I still enjoy the 80 db.
    It is not possible to have a conversation. I don't want hearing protection. Hearing damage after 10 days? Time will tell.

  30. Pieter says up

    You must have respect for a country and its inhabitants because you are a guest there. People in Myanmar are very friendly, I've been there myself. Of course he thought that this could also be done there, such as in the Netherlands, where you don't have to have any respect for the Dutch inhabitants and culture! Just when you point this out to guests, you already polarize or you are put in a certain right angle. I have traveled a lot, but the Netherlands is the only country in the world where guests have no respect and can do anything with impunity.

  31. Henk says up

    I find it strange that everyone thinks his sentence is too low because he has not performed a very smart action.
    I also find it strange that you have to learn all the ways and cultures by heart before you go on holiday in a certain country, which of course does not mean that you can just pull a plug from the turntable of the monks.
    I think it's just as strange that a temple has to turn up the sound system so loud that the whole city MUST hear it, I sometimes compare it to the walking street where I'm happy when I'm out again because of the deafening noise they make in my eyes drive away most of the “customers”.
    I find it even more strange that everyone knows exactly what we have to adhere to abroad while we come from the Netherlands / Belgium where the foreigners are going to tell that Zwarte Piet and Neger kisses and Jodenkoeken and so on are all no longer possible and allowed. we all just approve of that?? Do these people all get jail time? NO they get everything we as elderly people were actually entitled to !!
    Unplugging is not neat, but I regularly visit a temple where the monks are quietly playing with their cell phones and chatting or whatsapping and everyone thinks that's normal.
    Okay a stupid action but indeed a much too high punishment given by a country where everyone should be treated with respect, an admonishing word would have been enough.

  32. Lung addie says up

    This person has committed a rash act, there is no doubt about it. But I personally don't think it's a good idea to go to jail for 3 months for that. A just punishment would have been: a sincere apology, a hefty fine and immediate expulsion from the country with a ban on entering the country for X number of years (as was applied in Camboja). After all, it is not really a “criminal” act that this man committed, but rather stupidity. His excuse: I didn't know I was entering a temple is lame. I assume that you can definitely see the difference between a disco bar and a temple, even as a non-expert, unless you...
    As I read in another article, his girlfriend, and travel companion, has already chosen eggs for her money and is already back in the Netherlands. So he should not expect any support during his stay in the cell.

  33. Rob V says up

    The man has committed a very stupid and rude action. A decent person had complained to the hotel reception. Or at the organization of the party. Or finally with the police. Just explain in normal words that you are disturbed by the noise. Whether it would have been successful? It was only 22:00 PM, so it's hard to be surprised by a party or sermon at full volume.

    I don't understand the reactions along the lines of 'you are in a different country/world' or 'yes you shouldn't bother believers but accept'. In the Netherlands this would also have been a stupid rude action. And if this had not been a religious thing but a birthday party, wedding party or other event, the action would have been just as reprehensible. Religion does not need extra protection with extra severe punishments. No, a person has general universal standards of decency to apply. That means a bit of give and take, a bit of tolerance and not just thinking about yourself. Also put yourself in someone else's place. Engaging in dialogue, not just taking action. Pulling the plug is stupid caveman behavior, especially if you can think about what a normal, decent course of action would be during your angry hike to the installation.

    No, growling in prison is not a proper punishment. Personally, I would punish anyone who disrupts an event or party in such a way with a fine. Aggravating circumstances could then be 1) did the person have time to repent before committing the action? (Yes) 2) Was there indeed a nuisance caused by noise at an inhumane hour in the middle of the night? (No) 3) Does the perpetrator sincerely regret and realize what he or she has done? (no idea) 4) Is the person one with a past or is the person known as someone with a short fuse or aso behavior - if so, then heavier punishment -? (no idea if this man is a temper tantrum). If a fine were not sufficient for a perpetrator to make it clear that he was really wrong and will never do that again, then I would give the perpetrator appropriate community service as an additional punishment for a resident and leave the country for a tourist. to expand. Whether the act was committed in Burma, the Netherlands or elsewhere does not matter, such a criminal hearing seems to me to be in accordance with global/human norms and values.

  34. Janinne says up

    I've been quite annoyed by the headlines Klaas the world traveler!
    Well, I highly doubt that because then you would have been better prepared, and you would not have pulled this stupidity.
    Wonder if it was just about the plug? They had called the police because it was getting out of hand, and were not out for him to be arrested, a man told on TV.
    Anyway, our world traveler now has some time to think..... and a criminal record richer


Leave a comment

Thailandblog.nl uses cookies

Our website works best thanks to cookies. This way we can remember your settings, make you a personal offer and you help us improve the quality of the website. read more

Yes, I want a good website