Dear,

I would like to ask the following reader question:

Who has walked the “Belgium” route this year?

I (65+) would like to bring my girlfriend from Thailand to NL and wonder who can help me by sharing his experiences (pitfalls) with me. How difficult is it, what should I pay attention to, forms etc. etc.

risu

Thanks in advance signed Risu as I don't want my real name listed.

22 responses to “Reader question: Bringing a girlfriend from Thailand via the Belgium route”

  1. Rob V says up

    Have you already looked at the Foreign Partner Foundation site? The most essential is the steps that are well prepared and the steps that you follow during the Belgium (or other EU) route. The experience of people with a partner from another country who have their BP transferred via the BE/DE/… route is therefore very helpful.
    http://www.buitenlandsepartner.nl/forumdisplay.php?32-De-Belgi%EB-route

    Concrete information about Dutch people with a Thai BP with the EU route can of course be extra clear (arrange the same documents, etc. step by step), so I understand that it is nice if someone can share his/her experience on this blog.

    Good preparation is half the battle and even essential for the relatively complicated EU route (which I have no experience with myself). So make sure you can dream all the steps (don't lose sleep over them). Good luck!

  2. David555 says up

    https://dofi.ibz.be/sites/dvzoe/nl/documents/informatiebrochure_garanten.pdf

    Then start reading the Belgian requirements first (link Gov.be above), and moving to Belgium is the next step….

  3. Rory says up

    What I know from a Thai acquaintance and her friend is that, which can be checked via the site of the Belgian embassy, ​​the requirements in Belgium are practically the same as those in the Netherlands at the moment.
    The so-called Belgium route is a thing of the past.
    Sorry but that's what I know from someone trying to get to Turnhout. and has been doing this for over a year and a half now. He's been a Belgian all his life

    • Rob V says up

      @ Rori @David555 :
      The EU (Belgium, Germany, ...) route still exists and will continue to exist as long as there are no changes in European treaties regarding the EU movement of people. Via the EU route you are covered by these EU treaties and you have nothing to do with national legislation. For example, a German or Belgian can do the Netherlands route even though the Netherlands has one of the most strict migration legislation. You are subject to EU law and only have to meet those requirements. However, the authorities still try to make it difficult by cutting corners (so don't talk your mouth off when in contact with officials).

      In the past, this EU law was stricter than national legislation regarding immigration. As a resident of your own country, it was easier to bring your partner over than for another EU citizen (for example, a Belgian in the Netherlands or a Dutch citizen in Belgium). The requirements for our own people in our own country have now been tightened to such an extent that the requirements for our own residents in our own country are stricter/more disadvantageous than EU residents. For example, the Netherlands discriminates against its own residents in fact, since a Belgian living in the Netherlands can more easily bring over his foreign partner than a Belgian in Belgium, and a Dutch person in Belgium can more easily bring over his foreign partner than a Belgian in his own country.

      For example, is the Dutch cabinet happy with this? No, they also want to draw a line, but instead of synchronizing national legislation with the EU treaties, the Netherlands demands that the EU adapt its treaties to Dutch migration legislation. That is certainly hopeless in the short term, but in the meantime the discrimination against our own people continues.

      If you live close to the border, it would be advantageous to move across the border for a few months. Or if you live outside the EU and want to return to your country of birth, first live in another EU country for a few months. Have your partner come over and determine your residence status and then continue/return to your own EU country together. Pay close attention to the various pitfalls (such as transferring both at the same time if you move from one municipality to another and you have therefore demonstrably lived together at the same address all the time, 1 day difference at the official move and people already say "you have not lived together continuously” and then can play a role in naturalization, among other things).

      Check forum SBP for more details about the EU route, there are sub forums for Belgium, Germany, …. itineraries.

    • Dave says up

      You are missing the point: the Belgium route is for EU nationals, so not for someone who has Belgian nationality. It would be better for him to settle in the Netherlands. (Netherlands Route)

  4. Adrian Brooks says up

    Hi,

    It depends on where you live in the Netherlands, otherwise Germany may be a better alternative.
    In 2007 we ourselves lived across the border at Hardenberg for about 9 months and my Thai wife is now Dutch.
    I don't know if anything has changed in the EU route in those 7 years, but I don't think so.
    You can contact us on our email: [email protected]
    Regards,
    Adrie

  5. Rory says up

    My situation is I live in the Netherlands, my employer is Belgian and I work throughout Germany. My wife has been in the Netherlands for a little over 2 years now. I myself viewed and selected both routes in 2010/2011.
    For Germany you also have to first learn the language in Belgium or Flemish or French and for the Netherlands you have to know Dutch in basic.
    These rules are the biggest hurdle. The rest really means nothing. A fixed income above a certain minimum for at least 1 year. (also a WW benefit is an income, just like WAO etc). You have to guarantee. You can use a third party (family) for this (garnishment and salary), although the wage limit is then higher. You also need living space.

    What I think is the same is the language requirement and for that reason alone I would say try it via the Netherlands first.
    In the meantime I know many Thais who have done the naturalization together with my wife, all of them here for about a maximum of 3 years.
    If you fill in the forms properly and submit everything properly, there will be few problems. Just keep track of where the documents go and are.
    Go via or directly or via Zoetermeer to 's-Hertogenbosch then to Zwolle, then again to Zoetermeer and then you get permission yes or no.

    My wife has been to the Netherlands twice as a friend. Everything arranged through the info center in Eindhoven. After that, in the beginning every week for the MVV went to the IND info center in Eindhoven to ask where the papers were and what the status is.
    Has helped a lot. MVV application within 6 weeks.
    .

  6. kees1 says up

    I have heard more about that Belgium route.
    and thought I'd see what's so good about that. Now I read that you have to move to Belgium. Then you can hardly call that interesting. Not that I have anything against the Belgian. But then I would say make that step just one step and then move to Thailand. You don't need that hellish route anymore
    Greetings Kees

  7. BA says up

    I also took a quick look at it, but I don't really understand the benefit either.

    Is this purely to avoid the income requirement? Or does this also provide advantages with regard to the integration course?

    My girlfriend is currently in the Netherlands. What really surprised me is that she received a 3-month single entry visa the first time. But with the 2nd application, no more questions were actually asked, only whether she stayed with the same partner. And then a Multi entry visa for 1 year was also issued without any questions. So she can just fly in and out for the next year as long as she doesn't stay within 90 for longer than 180 days. And at Schiphol she could just walk straight through, she was just asked about her return journey and that's it.

    Moving to MVV suddenly seems a lot less difficult to me, in any case, if we change our mind and we want to stay in NL.

  8. Rob V says up

    There are only advantages to it, but I don't know the details either, since I'm not an expert by experience. Benefits include:

    – no Dutch or Belgian income requirement (sustainable and sufficient income such as this money for the MVV / TEV procedure) but only that you can keep your own pants (support yourself).
    – No integration obligation abroad (exam at the embassy) and no integration obligation at home. For naturalization one must of course be integrated.
    – More favorable condition/rights with regard to the residence permit (which I dare not say exactly, on SBP there is a piece about EU route migrants who initially received a wrong, less favorable residence permit and exchange it for the correct pass/residence permit. This mistake makes the IND still every now and then I read on the SBP forum).
    – Much lower fees (normally you pay something like 250 euros, Turks 60 euros, EU goers I think too and Israelis pay nothing at all... due to all kinds of treaties there are different fees/requirements/rights for various 'categories' of people)
    – … ??? (consult an expert and/or EU route manual for more ins and outs.

    The biggest disadvantage of the EU route is that you have to go through the steps very carefully because the government sees the EU route as an abuse of EU rights... laughable when you realize that in the EU (Schengen) there is free movement of people, etc. of immigrants. Migration policy should therefore actually be drawn up universally EU/Schengen-wide... then there will be nothing to "circumvent" within the open borders. Second disadvantage: you must of course be able to move to another EU country for at least 3 months.

  9. John Hoekstra says up

    The easiest way is to take the civic integration exam in Bangkok and simply stay in the Netherlands, even with an AOW it is possible to apply for an MVV for your girlfriend. My girlfriend studied with Richard van der Kieft, she and I liked that, maybe you can approach him if you have any questions. Website http://www.nederlandslerenbangkok.com

    Good luck.

    Greetings,

    John Hoekstra

  10. Khung Chiang Moi says up

    Why so complicated via Belgium the so-called Belgium route? I often read that the rules in the Netherlands are strict and the Netherlands is difficult ……. yes the rules are strict but fair. In short, if you comply with the rules, it is no problem at all. The most important is the income requirement 1478 gross income, which is the one most people have, if you don't have that, then you should ask yourself whether you have something to offer someone (your girlfriend) in the Netherlands, after all, you have to (for now) be able to live on 1 income, you must also have a place to live, that does not seem to me to be an unfair requirement. You must demonstrate that the relationship is sustainable, that is to say that you must have known her for a little longer than a very short time. You can demonstrate this with photos of you standing together, airline tickets, hotel reservations. It also helps a lot if your girlfriend has already been to the Netherlands for a holiday.
    I have now brought my girlfriend who I have known for 2 years and who has been in the Netherlands twice for 2 months to the Netherlands permanently, we now live together (in the Netherlands) and are happy. She now has a residence permit for 3 years, the actual application took 5 weeks and without any problems, so it is not that difficult. Of course you have to meet the requirements, but is that unfair? You should also see it as a bit of protection for your girlfriend and yourself. You want to live as “normal” a life as possible in the Netherlands and all those so-called shortcuts, no matter how legal, prove that people probably do not meet the requirements, which are very logical, after all. If people do not meet this requirement, I would say “don't start,” but that is my view.

    • Adrian Brooks says up

      @Khun Chiang Moi:
      However, the 1478 euros you mention in your response is not gross but net, as a requirement for an MVV.
      I think that amount has since been increased a bit.

      • Adrian Brooks says up

        Sorry, I responded too quickly.
        Previously (2007) it was net, but now it seems to be indeed gross.
        So that has changed for the better.
        In that case I would simply opt for an MVV, the fees are high, but emigration to another EU country also costs a lot, not to mention all the inconveniences that entails.

  11. Rob V says up

    People can do this for several reasons:
    – Not being able to meet the income requirement because your 1) contract no longer runs for 365 days when the application is received at the IND (one day too late and you get negative, a contract that runs for 364 days is not sustainable enough) 2 ) works as a temporary / on-call worker or other such basis 3) cannot meet the income requirement for other reasons, such as just a euro too little, as an entrepreneur you cannot meet the income requirements that apply to them, etc. and on paper therefore no “ sustainable and sufficient” income, but in practice earn enough and/or have enough money behind.
    – Problems with integration at home/abroad: yes, exemptions can be obtained for this after many attempts (in any case, integration at home, exemption for integration abroad -WIB- is almost impossible to do, that has only happened twice since the introduction of the WIB ).

    It can be difficult to meet the income requirement, especially for starters on the labor market, i.e. young people. These days you don't get an annual contract (or permanent contract) so quickly. If you have just lost your job, it can also become difficult even if you have just found a new job.

    It can also simply come true, if you are just planning to move yourself, why not (temporarily) in a neighboring EU country if you are filling up your moving van from the Netherlands or another country?

    The integration requirements seem fair at first glance, but they are also quite patronizing, under the guise of “the good must suffer because of the bad”. They actually assume that the foreigner may have the wrong intentions and comes from a backward country (I think the questions from the WIB, among others, are pitiful and ultimately most knowledge is of little or no use to you: “was the king of Spain Catholic or Protestant?" "Do you receive benefits or does your partner have to take care of you?" Unfortunately, people who are perfectly fine in practice (keep their own pants on, will normally participate in society, etc.) get stuck in this problem. but not on paper. Well then you hang nice, and the EU route offers a nice escape.

    For most people with a foreign (Thai) partner, the regular route (MVV / TEV) is doable and easiest, but the EU route has its uses. The latter is probably also the case for the writer of this reader's question?

    • Khung Chiang Moi says up

      Of course there are all kinds of reasons to do the foreign route, but I refer to the writer's submitted piece, he states that he is 65+, so having a permanent job or otherwise does not apply in his case. Their income must be 1470 gross AOW incl. any pension, no more and no less. Of course there are rules and they must be there in a society that those rules do not suit everyone, that is a fact. Rules are also there to protect people so that they do not get into trouble. Please note that bringing someone to the Netherlands to live here certainly entails risks and in those cases where things go wrong, one cannot rightly rely on the Dutch government, nor should the Thai government. So it is good that there are rules ALSO for people who do not have a permanent employment contract or have not worked for the required period. 1 day shortage is of course unpleasant, but where should you set the limit? There will always be cases that just do not meet the conditions where that limit also lies.

  12. Mr. Bojangles says up

    My girlfriend can't read or write. So we can forget about that integration course.
    Logically? fair? that according to the normal rules she should never ever live here?
    I personally find it ridiculous.

    And, no, you don't have to move to Belgium. you only have to live there for 7 months, so rent for example.

    • David555 says up

      your quote;
      “And, no, you don't have to move to Belgium. you only have to live there for 7 months, so rent for example.”

      So that's moving.!!... short or long, temporary or permanent... it doesn't matter, but "living" is registered with his population service, don't understand what else you mean by moving?

      Whether it is “Flemish Dutch” or “Dutch Dutch”…..

    • Rob V says up

      @ mr. Boyangles. Illiteracy, as far as we know, is not enough for an exemption from all or even part of the test. They demand that the stranger just try it a few times (checkout $$$ !!) and then an appeal can be made to striding. That was only given twice until the end of 2012 and that test has existed since 2. Too sad for words. They must be afraid of scammers or something (plus rules are rules… )

      More info take a look at:
      - http://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/inburgering-en-integratie/vraag-en-antwoord/kan-ik-ontheffing-krijgen-voor-een-inburgeringsexamen.html
      – topics like http://www.buitenlandsepartner.nl/showthread.php?54564-Hoe-een-Cambodjaanse-analfabeet-Nederlands-te-leren

      @ Rhudolf, you were an expert by experience I think I remember now? What you write seems to be in line with what I have heard about the EU route. You really have to be very careful with your words. If you move back soon, they will almost certainly go fishing and there are also (Belgian) municipalities that sometimes ask questions. Then you must be so wise as not to speak your mouth. As an EU national, you officially went to live in the municipality of a neighboring country and returned after x months. They don't need to know more (besides a mountain of evidence).

      @ everyone: put everything you encounter in terms of unfairness or that you consider inhumane on paper and send an email to politicians. I did too. SP and GL respond positively, D66 to a certain extent, even though they know of no alternative to the income requirement that offers just as much certainty. The rest of the politicians, PcdA, VVD, CDA, PVV, SGP, CU are not worried about it. At best a response with “understanding the disadvantages of the system, but you will get there in the end and we really have to stop the bad apples”. Don't expect miracles, but not shooting is always wrong. Sending a letter never hurts, maybe parties will eventually agree to something or completely... For example, the PvdA etc. is full of talk about human and social policy, about asylum policy and illegal immigrants, but as a Dutch person with a foreign partner you can still get by. By the way, there has also been a lot of professional criticism of the integration exam (TGN speech computer), but there has also been little success because so far the ministers have waved away the heavy criticism. That's it for this bit of background information.

  13. KhunRudolf says up

    The Belgium route is often considered if obstacles are expected in the normal procedure towards the Netherlands. Eg. shortage of income. But renting a house in Belgium and maintaining your girlfriend there will also cost money. You also have to live in Belgium yourself, and after that year you can go to the Netherlands together. In that year you therefore have all kinds of double costs, apart from the rent. The EU regulations refer to a period of 7 months living in, for example, Belgium. If you come to Ned exactly after 7 months, annoying questions will be asked, because everyone will understand that you lived in Belgium to circumvent regulations.
    If the route is used because, for example, the Thai girlfriend cannot read and write, then realize that she will not have a pleasant time in the Netherlands (first in Belgium) due to a lack of basic skills. If she doesn't already master these techniques in her own language, it won't be easy for her. This can be solved by first teaching your girlfriend in Thailand to read and write, there is nothing wrong with that and cheaper than renting an extra house. There are plenty of people in Thailand who can teach. With these basic skills, she will be able to function better and more favorably in the Netherlands. Please bear in mind that sooner or later every foreigner who has indicated that he wants to settle in the Netherlands will eventually be called upon to follow language courses, etc.
    If the route is used to avoid bureaucracy and procedures, you will be in for a surprise, because this route also requires bureaucracy and documentation. Not a single neighboring country of the Netherlands is waiting for people to use 'stealth' routes. Beware of readers who react from their armchair in The Hague as if this route can be done without having to take a single step yourself. The Belgium route is one that you have to think about carefully because the organization around it requires a lot of practical action.
    Finally: after a year in Belgium, your partner has to switch again because 'real' life starts in the Netherlands. You are also far from getting rid of bureaucracy and regulations.

  14. mulder says up

    Take a look at the foreign partner's site, it contains everything you need to know or almost

  15. Frits Bosveld says up

    I did the Belgium route last year with my Thai wife. I liked it. She could not read or write either. That was one of the reasons for choosing this route. In Belgium, my wife went to basic education and learned Dutch there, which costs almost nothing. This is on a voluntary basis. There are of course several pitfalls, but these can be overcome. If you want to know something, just send me an email [email protected].


Leave a comment

Thailandblog.nl uses cookies

Our website works best thanks to cookies. This way we can remember your settings, make you a personal offer and you help us improve the quality of the website. read more

Yes, I want a good website