Dear readers,

The last contributions about solar panels on Thailandblog are already about a year old. I wonder if anyone has had experience with solar energy in Thailand recently?

We are investigating whether this is a good alternative to connecting to the public grid. Given the distance to the last connection, the latter is also quite expensive. We are mainly concerned with costs and reliability, whereby the lack of a mains connection means that it must be a system in which electricity is also stored.

We appreciate it when people take the trouble to write advice based on opinions or on "hearing from" here, but we're really only looking for our own experiences from others.

Regards,

Francois Nang Lae

29 responses to “Reader question: Who has (recent) experience with solar panels?”

  1. Jo says up

    I also checked it, not because we are far from the connection, but because the power often wants to go out and because of the slow start-up, electrical appliances want to die. With us the dishwasher and washing machine. So I wanted to install solar panels with a battery so that there is always a constant voltage in the house.
    A good battery costs quite a bit
    https://www.tesla.com/nl_NL/powerwall?redirect=no

    So I decided against it, partly because supplying it back to the grid is more difficult here than in NL and for the money of a battery I can occasionally buy a new washing machine.

    • ruud says up

      I once saw someone have a box that only passes on the current when the voltage rises above a set value.
      That will probably cost less than a new washing machine.

  2. Fransamsterdam says up

    You want to store the energy. Batteries are required for this. They are expensive, heavy, limited in capacity, and break down over time. No spectacular progress is to be expected in the coming years unless someone comes up with a genius revolutionary idea.
    Forget about all the announcements and commercials.
    Since 2005 I have been waiting in vain for a simple small battery for the phone that charges quickly. According to Toshiba, it would come on the market in 2006, but when I inquired in 2015, I was told that the product was 'never commercialized'.
    .
    https://fransamsterdam.com/2015/09/10/batterij-opladen-in-1-minuut-charge-battery-in-1-minute/
    .
    The electric car will therefore not make it again.
    There are ways to store electricity at home, but it is extremely expensive.
    An aggregate is more obvious.

    https://www.zonnefabriek.nl/nieuws/batterij-opslag-voor-zonne-energie-iets-voor-u/

    • Jos says up

      In the Netherlands you can supply back to the grid, then no batteries are needed.
      Is that not possible in Thailand?

      • Fransamsterdam says up

        They want to do without a grid connection at all, because connecting to it is quite expensive.

  3. Dirk De Witte says up

    Dear,

    As in that last message, a generator is perhaps the cheapest and not expensive.
    Honda supplies light “silent” and compact generators and provided two or three jerry cans of gasoline (2-stroke?)
    do you have spare.

    Well, maybe there is not enough power to power a washing machine, dishwasher and iron, but more than enough for TV, radio and LED lighting.

    Dirk

  4. Ed says up

    We have found a very reliable solar business in Chiang Mai, ABO trading. The business is run by an Italian who knows a lot about business. Several times he gave us advice about the swimming pool because the Thai builder gave us wrong advice because he wanted to sell us an ordinary ac pump. The pump of the swimming pool and the pump of the pond run effortlessly on the solar. He honestly told us that storing energy with a battery is not yet sufficiently developed in Thailand.
    What can be done well is obtaining hot water via solar.

  5. hans says up

    I have had 3 solar panels for 18 years now and I am very satisfied with them, only the friends of the PEA (Provincial Electricity Authority) have messed things up, they think it is dangerous for them if the meter turns backwards so that if they work on the cables and the have turned off electricity that one of the motors can still fall dead from my solar panels power. I explained to the basket if he wants to talk about cycling he must first learn to cycle, in other words he must first learn about solar panels and then he will learn as soon as there is no more power on the system, the solar panels will no longer supply power. But that put I think bad blood and now got a meter that cannot turn back so during the day it stands still and at night it turns up the position so I have little benefit left I went from 6500 Bht/month without solar panels to 1700 Bht/month with and now 2500Bht/month with the fucking meter! and then I have the trick that I turn off all refrigerators at 4 am and start them again at 8 am when the sun is shining. Batteries are not an option as they are prohibitively expensive and have a lifespan of only a few years.

    • ruud says up

      In the Netherlands you must have a contract with your energy supplier for the return of electricity.
      There, too, you cannot simply turn the meter back with solar panels.
      Apparently not in Thailand either.

      Furthermore, not every system with solar panels is suitable for feeding back electricity.
      There are also systems that will also simply send 220 volts into the grid if the mains voltage fails.
      The man from the PEA is right about that.

  6. tooske says up

    I've had solar panels for over 5 years now and they work perfectly.
    BUT: I connected them to the net (grid tied)
    But the most important advice is get connected to the net if this is even possible.
    A generator alone is not an option, it can only serve as a back-up in the event of a power failure.
    Panels with batteries are then an option, but depending on your daily consumption in Kw.

    if you stay within 10 Kw per day then something is possible even without the expensive tesla battery but with industrial or golf cart batteries.
    If you want advice, I'd be happy to help you.

  7. Fransamsterdam says up

    Of course, it also depends on what that connection to the network costs. 'Pretty expensive' doesn't mean much to me. €5000? €20.000?
    But being completely without a mains connection is also quite something. Those 'storage batteries' are actually not intended for that and I fear that they will be broken even sooner than with 'normal' use.
    I would definitely like that grid connection. Is also a good investment if you ever want or need to sell the house. Without a grid connection, it will at least reduce the costs of the connection, but then again without you having benefited from it yourself.

  8. Jan says up

    Dear Frans, I think it is much better to take a mains connection, less expensive and not so complicated than to make electricity yourself. In addition, I have bought a fully automatic voltage regulator, which, if the current is too low, for example - 200 V, automatically sends the current to 230 V, even if there is only 190 V on the grid.
    I also installed a lightning protector, which also prevents many problems.
    There are also special LED lamps for sale that have a built-in battery and provide several hours of light.
    If you are without power for days now and it happens more where you live, you can still purchase a small generator, which also does not cost that much.
    I haven't been without power for more than 6 hours here.
    I also have a water heating system with solar energy that works great and always gives hot water for shower, washing and kitchen.
    Regards,
    Jan

    • Georges says up

      Jan

      Very interesting what you say.
      I see here, for example, yesterday that the mains voltage does not reach 190.
      Am really interested in that voltage regulator.
      I do have a lightning protector.
      And I also have those special lamps.
      But sometimes the power goes out here for hours.
      Then just turn on the lights.
      And then think about how many amps that generator must supply?
      I live in Chaiyaphum, no mains water, everything powered by electricity = pumps of 1.500 watts

      regards

      Georges

  9. Martin says up

    Solar panels are 12V, if you install (a 2nd?) electricity network at home in 12V in collaboration with LED lighting, you can use simple batteries in dark light / radio etc, refrigerator also works (camping model)

    If you do washing and heavy power tractors during the day, when the sun is out, you should still come a long way.

  10. joop says up

    Check these out…

    http://www.kreiselenergy.com/

  11. peter says up

    It's mainly about, what do you use in kW in the evening?
    Heavy boys are of course the refrigerator, washing machine and AC (possibly), if you cook electrically, plates or microwave or otherwise, that costs power.
    In terms of lighting, you can of course use as many LED lamps as possible, which saves money.
    You have LED lamps of 10 W with 1000 lumens, which give good light. Can be less natural, saves, but gives less light, eg 3 w 300 lumens.

    You see batteries of 12V 200Ah on alibaba. Varying in prices and warranty, everything ex transport costs of course. These weigh +/- 60 kg/piece.
    Lipo batteries again save a lot of weight, but are more expensive and require a special charger.
    Smaller batteries 90 Ah weigh less, but then you need more.

    With 12V 200Ah you can theoretically get an inverter 230V 10 Ah on the secondary side, all that for 1 hour, after that the battery is empty. Now you will not use 10 A continuously in an hour (??), but this is not possible due to cabling.
    so you need several batteries.
    Whatever you want, of course, and depending on what you want to feed. You see various batteries and prices,

    Cabling is also an issue, the larger the diameter of the cable, the less power loss, so more efficient, so better. Also the material, is it pure copper or an alloy? Is used in Asian countries to reduce cable costs. You have to connect several batteries in parallel.

    As the amperage increases on the primary side (12V), the cable can get warm and possibly even hot with insufficient diameter, after all 200 A is quite a bit. I actually wonder which cable should be for it, since at 12V max 30 amps can flow through a 4 mm2 cable at a distance of max 1 meter. https://www.rfsystems.nl/techniek/Kabeldoorsnede_12V_24V_LED.pdf
    So briefly to the inverter. 200 A from a battery is therefore NOT an option.

    By doubling the cables, you can then draw a maximum of 60 A from a battery. i
    This means that you need at least 10 batteries for 230 A secondary side (4 volts) and have this secured on EACH battery (60 A). So is 240 A primary and secondary 12(.5217) A
    I am only left with the problem, where the cables come together and 240 A flows. So it should be a copper strip attachment
    But the batteries will continue to deliver longer. At 10 A continuous, so about 3 hours.
    Maintenance also plays a role, as resistance increases when the cable is oxidized and efficiency drops. And it is humid in Thailand. Greasing with a non-conductive grease (vaseline) on the connections helps a lot.

    With a 15-year warranty, the battery costs USD 200 per piece excluding shipping, transport, so they weigh about 60 kg.
    thus a train of thought

  12. Am scented says up

    I have equipped my house with 16 earth leakage circuit breakers and a system that switches off the house if the mains voltage is too high or too low and switches the house back on when the voltage is stable for about 4 minutes within certain limits N (adjustable). A main safety of 63A was immediately installed.
    Cost of material for voltage monitoring approx. 3500 BHT.
    So no burnt coils of swimming pool controls, etc. afterwards
    Ben

    • Hans San says up

      Hello Ben,
      I am very curious about your solution. Since it's not about solar panels and might get a bit too detailed for the Blog, I'd appreciate it if we could speak directly.
      Would you like to call me on +66 6 367 487 23.

  13. Pieter says up

    I read this in a magazine today, perhaps a new development in batteries especially for solar cells:
    https://www.deingenieur.nl/artikel/nieuw-soort-batterij-bij-melkboer

  14. Pieter says up

    But it can be even crazier, also read in 'de Ingenieur':
    https://www.deingenieur.nl/artikel/eerste-appartementen-op-gelijkstroom

    • Fransamsterdam says up

      Oh my Buddha, who makes it up? Providing the residents of the top floor of a residential complex with 250 Volt direct current instead of 220 Volt alternating current.
      “One of the goals of the project is to investigate how residents can reduce their energy consumption.”
      Yes, that answer is obvious. Stop using devices that don't want to run on direct current. And maybe just walk the last flight of stairs, I don't know if an elevator will go crazy on direct current.
      What kind of crazy country is that?

  15. lung addie says up

    I also had the idea of ​​doing something with solar energy, but I have shelved the project because it was “not profitable”.
    If you want to work completely autonomously, so no mains connection, then you need a decent installation with sufficient storage capacity. Also keep in mind that the panels here achieve a lower efficiency than in Europe due to the heat. By the way, you need “light” and not heat.
    Start with a proper calculation of the required power over a period of 24 hours. Multiply this by factor 4 to calculate the capacity of the panels. Know that you only have half of the sunlight per day, so you need to be able to produce enough during the hours of sunlight to cover the non-productive hours. That is as a factor 2 and the other 2 to absorb the losses regarding efficiency and consumption of the peripheral equipment, voltage regulator, converter to 220V and also wa So you will need a large storage capacity.

  16. lung addie says up

    I also had the idea of ​​doing something with solar energy, but I have shelved the project because it was “not profitable”.
    If you want to work completely autonomously, so no mains connection, then you need a decent installation with sufficient storage capacity. Also keep in mind that the panels here achieve a lower efficiency than in Europe due to the heat. By the way, you need “light” and not heat.
    First start with a proper calculation of the required power over a period of 24 hours. Multiply this by a factor of 4 to calculate the capacity of the panels. Remember that you only have half of the sunlight per day, so you need to be able to produce enough during the sunlight hours to compensate for the unproductive hours. That is already factor 2 and the other 2 is to absorb the losses regarding efficiency and consumption of the peripheral equipment, voltage regulator, converter to 220V and also to have some reserve. You will need a large storage capacity, batteries and they are expensive, at least if you want good batteries (e.g. traction batteries).
    I myself sit 200m from the street and had to provide the power line to the grid myself: 2 x 10mm² 200m with a concrete pole and insulators every 30m. This did not outweigh the installation costs of solar panels. It would have taken me at least 10 years of consumption to recoup the installation costs, not to mention the maintenance costs. As long as the price per kW/h does not double, it is not feasible.

  17. Robbie says up

    I'm thinking about it too. Not so much to save money but more to cope with the regular power outages here on Samui, Electrical equipment still takes a hit every time the power goes out. I was thinking and solar panels with a Tesla battery. However, they are indeed very pricey

    • ruud says up

      You could also consider taking only a backup power supply.
      A battery that is charged by the mains and that releases power when no more power is supplied.
      That saves a lot of hassle with solar panels.

  18. antoine says up

    It is really looking for a decent solution. All I see is Tesla's powerwall.
    What I'm working with now is from goal zero https://www.solarpowersupply.nl
    Maybe that will help you
    I only use this to charge my laptop and smart and smaller power banks. You certainly shouldn't do this to work cheaply. I also do it a bit for nature. Save the world starts with yourself my idea.
    If there is anyone who knows the goal zero for sale in Thailand, they can always send me an email
    [email protected]

  19. Herman buts says up

    has anyone ever thought of installing an isolating transformer to compensate for the voltage variations?

    • peter says up

      A transformer is connected to a power supply anyway, so the varying 230 volts, so the output voltage will also vary. Isolation transformer is only for safety, to disconnect from the mains.

      I think an inverter would help. Not sure and only come across inverters up to 2kW.
      There are some that can have a variable input of 95 – 264Vac (universal input). However, I do not dare to say whether the output is kept equal when varying the input, should receive an explanation from the manufacturer then. It would seem so to me, given power supplies for various devices with such an input, but the output voltage is usually lower there. However, read that in the description of the model below.
      It matters whether a stereo or TV is on it. You have switching and pure sine wave inverters.
      For your audio/TV you need a pure sine wave. Washing machines, computers or other electronic devices with electronic controls can get confused with a switching power supply, I have learned from reading.
      However, the washing machine then exceeds 2 kW when using a heater. So is your hot water shower of course.

      bv http://www.amtex.com.au/power_pdf/FC2K.pdf

  20. Francois Nang Lae says up

    Thank you all for the sometimes very detailed responses. We will look into it further and then decide whether it will be solar panels or grid power.


Leave a comment

Thailandblog.nl uses cookies

Our website works best thanks to cookies. This way we can remember your settings, make you a personal offer and you help us improve the quality of the website. read more

Yes, I want a good website