Isan opposition to potassium mining
There is a consensus among certain Thai populations that the people of Isaan are a bunch of backward assholes. They don't pay taxes and stubbornly vote for the wrong politicians. Not even the military can help with the latter…
Some prominent members of the Bangkok Hi so in the past expressed the opinion that it is better to halve the votes cast in Isaan, but in fact most of the elite in the City of Angels believe that they should simply not be allowed to vote anymore. Not so long ago, there was another riot when Suchai Butsara, the deputy governor of Khon Kaen, described the inhabitants of Isan as stupid in a letter. It turned out to be the proverbial storm in the equally proverbial glass of water…
The inhabitants of Isaan may be known in certain circles as inveterate stupids, but I certainly don't experience them that way. Living together for twelve years with a very articulate and politically conscious Isan and living on the border of Buriram with Surin for quite some time now, I may not yet call myself an expert, but I can call myself an expert by experience. I experience my Isan fellow citizens as eloquent citizens, perhaps cursed with what is colloquially known as 'common sense' is described but what's wrong with that? Moreover, they have outspoken opinions, which they want to pass on to God and Klein Pierke - as they used to say with us in the Kempen. They may not express their opinion as eloquently or academically substantiated as the Bangkok elite, but unlike the Hi so a heart for their local community and are also willing to show this. For example, environmental awareness is a natural thing for them. As smallholder rice farmers and livestock farmers, they know that their survival depends on a harmonious and respectful coexistence of people, animals and nature. They may sometimes be a bit too lavish with spraying substances, but it is not surprising that when this survival is threatened at the core, the population will rebel. That is why I would like to take a moment to reflect on the protest in Sakhon Nakhon, largely silenced by the major Thai media, against the possible extraction of potassium by the Chinese.
Potassium or potassium was extracted for centuries in the West from potash, the water-soaked or leached ash of oak or beech wood that was dried in order to extract potassium from it. In the nineteenth century it was discovered that potassium can also be extracted from mines as a finite and non-replaceable resource. Fortunately, huge stocks still exist, especially in Canada, China, Russia and Belarus. More than 90% of all extracted potassium salts are processed as potassium chloride in fertilizer. As a result, they are important for food production and it is not unexpected, for example, that a country such as the People's Republic of China, always eager for strategic acquisitions, wants to secure its food production by strengthening its grip on global potassium extraction.
Coincidentally, the subsurface of Isaan may also hide an interesting supply of potassium. Almost twenty years ago, a Canadian company first tried to extract potassium in Udon Thani. Without much trouble, a favorable environmental impact assessment was drawn up and they obtained a license, but thanks to the protest of the local population, these plans remained. After all, the population feared – and who can blame them? – that this whole business can indeed have an impact on the environment that is much more serious than what was told by the applicants. Potassium mining has a reputation for not only having a possible impact on the landscape and the surrounding ecosystem, but also being responsible for water pollution, excessive water use and air pollution. Effects, which are confirmed in studies by respectable institutions such as the United Nations Environment Program and even the International Fertilizer Association.
In 2015 the . received China Ming Ta Potash Corporation a five-year license to prospect in Sakhon Nakhon province for potassium mining in an area of 120.000 rai with a focus on Wanon Niwat district. Concerned about the environment, residents took action two years ago. A campaign that in December 2018 resulted in the 'Wanon Walk', a closely monitored military and police six-day protest march by 200 villagers to the provincial capital. An action that only received some publicity in the local press. The national media barely responded. In March 2019, a ceremony was held at the endangered Huay Thong reservoir to implore the protection of the spirits over this water resource… I honestly doubt that such actions will impress the Chinese who believe that everything, absolutely everything, in the world and certainly in South East Asia…
Meanwhile, the clock is ticking mercilessly. The Chinese license will expire in less than half a year and there is a good chance that no one, and certainly not Phrayut Chan-o-Cha's cabinet, will stand in their way. Who in Bangkok is also awake from Isaan…?
About this blogger
Read the latest articles here
- BackgroundDecember 28 2024Thailand is a noodle paradise
- BackgroundDecember 10 2024Wat Phra That Phanom: Pearl of the Mekong Valley
- BackgroundNovember 29 2024Wat Phra Kaew: The Temple of the Emerald Buddha
- SightsNovember 24 2024The Ling Buai Ia Shrine in Bangkok
Deputy Governor Suchai labeled them โง่ (fool, idiot, stupid, stupid) in early 2018.
https://www.thailandblog.nl/opmerkelijk/vergadering-om-isaners-domheid-genezen/
Much has been written about looking down on the 'stupid Isaaner'. They are therefore not 'real Thai' but Lao and Khmer… Well give me the people with common sense. And I sincerely hope they don't let nature destroy it. However, if Bangkok sets its sights on something…
https://www.thailandblog.nl/achtergrond/isaaners-zijn-geen-thai-wie-mag-zich-thai-noemen-het-uitwissen-van-de-plaatselijke-identiteit/
I have my strong doubts about the “common common sense”… About 9 years ago my “in-laws” started the excessive spraying… The grandfather saw how the rice came up strong for one year, but the fish and crabs in the rice fields disappeared. Sprayed to pieces… A year later the weeds took their revenge and came back twice as hard. What did the Isanians do? Right, yes… spray more… a lot more. Meanwhile, a niece and an uncle died of an aggressive cancer. Think carefully and rinse the rice you eat at least 3 times before preparation. Isaaners, like every Thai, think of "income" and it will not matter to them whether or not the harvest is "poisoned" ... MONEY is what COUNTS .... (and that is why there are so many Isan beauties in Pattaya ) Alas!
The grandfather spent a lot of time on his rice fields at the time (years ago). Now it all has to go fast and yield quickly... Production has to be done in a fraction of the time. Health doesn't count. Neither feel….”Cash Now” is the rule.
That is a mistake not only made in Thailand.
Also in NL people look down on people from outside.
According to our politicians, the Randstad is the Netherlands and outside it is often forgotten.
When I look at how all the facilities are eroded in my old living environment (eg public transport, healthcare) tears well up in my eyes.
I always compare the Isaan with Nl in the time when my parents were still children.
This is true before, during and just after WWII, but even in those years there was no money to send the children to school. Working from primary school was the norm in those years and the money earned was also largely paid at home.
I am convinced that many from that time (and now in the Isaan) would have had a better future if there was (is) money for a good education.
Bert, I think your opinion about the Netherlands is exaggerated. The politicians often come from outside the Randstad, so they really know what is going on among the population.
And the Netherlands is a small busy country.
Isaan is just a win-region for Bangkok, isn't it? For centuries (semi) occupied territory.
Just look at the tax revenues and expenditures (was once an appendix to the elections or on Thai Visa or on this site. Bangkok first, second, third and fourth.
quote: “There is a consensus among certain Thai populations that the people of Isan are a bunch of backward assholes.”
I don't know which population groups Lung Jan is talking about here, but the picture of the political and socio-economic differences between Isaan and Bangkok is an outdated picture. I live in Bangkok in a working-class neighborhood and with me thousands of Isaners who live here partly not officially, but in reality.
And if you analyze the voting behavior of the Thais in the last election, you see that Prayut's party has won many votes in previously red areas and that whole parts of Bangkok are voting red (from people who are also registered here). After that, the Thai elite lives all over the country and not specifically in Bangkok.
The contrast is an image that is perhaps gladly maintained (by whom, actually?), but it is just such an image as the Randstad dweller who looks down on the Achterhoeker, the Limburger and the East-Groninger. One of my colleagues, a real Bangkok resident, has been supporting action groups with his research for years now.
So let's stop with this contrived contradiction.
You might ask what is really stupid?
If a government can't tell the difference between being stupid or having a bad education, of which they themselves bear the greatest debt to the latter, you might also ask how stupid is this government itself that they let so many hidden talents go to waste.
“stupid Isarners”?
When tomorrow all the people from Isarn stop working throughout Thailand for one week, the whole of Thailand will be on its ass!! All airports, large malls, taxi and motorcycle drivers, delivery drivers, bus and truck drivers, garbage collectors, in short, all necessary work!
And with this the economy gets a horrific blow!! I wouldn't say bankrupt just yet.
Hmm How can an observation and an opinion differ, even if you are looking at exactly the same thing….
The centripetal force plays a strong role in Thailand. No doubt much stronger than the perception of it.
French Paris or the Dutch Randstad are also perceived as centripetal. And the Flemish car park in reverse.
It is cultivating another form of inequality. Inequality that is already unimaginably extreme in Thailand.
It was about potassium extraction in the beginning and ends with politics. I think the disadvantage in Isaan of education and employment is true, but it is also maintained by its own population. As soon as one needs something from an authority in Isaan (with or without uniform), tea money is provided. I don't think the word corruption exists here. It is now interwoven in the culture. For example, if the sor por kor land is to be measured by the land bureau, the waiting time is one year. It can also be done in a month. How? Tea money for 1) pooj job. 2) country officer. 3) Surveyors come on their day off (4 men) for 500 baht per man with tools from the boss. Do they want to eat too?
Nevertheless, I know that potassium extraction is a disaster for water where there is not too much of it, I thought. The Meuse was heavily polluted for decades by the potash mines in France. So hold back.